Updated: Within 24 hours of posting this review the Custom Genie team reached out. They sent my order right away and gave me a credit toward a future order. Though the initial experience was disappo... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Review summary
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
What people talk about most
Reviews shaping this summary
We have several name tags from Name Badges Int'l whom you absorbed. The ones we just got from you seem lesser quality. They are printed slightly off center, so the white edge shows slightly more on o... See more
Company replied
The name badges I ordered came in a timely manner and were perfect. I order pretty frequently when we have new hires or existing staff have lost their badges. The only reason I gave 4 stars instead of... See more
Company replied
The order arrived in suitable time - though at the end of the 7-day timeframe posted on the website. Each order I've placed, including this one, have been suitably packaged and have arrived in good c... See more
Company details
About Customgenie
Written by the company
Custom Genie specializes in beautiful, high-quality personalized products that help brands make a lasting impression. Headquartered in Atlanta, GA, our North American manufacturing and distribution facility houses a full in-house art department, a dedicated customer service team, and a state-of-the-art production floor — giving us complete control over every detail from first sketch to final shipment.
We proudly serve a wide and diverse client base, including hospitality, retail, personal and professional services, public bodies, airlines, the financial sector, and travel. Whether you need branded drinkware for a corporate event, premium giveaways for a trade show, or fully customized merchandise for retail shelves, our team delivers products built to elevate your brand.
Every order is handled with precision and care. From concept and artwork proofs to packaging and shipping, our experts ensure your company logo looks polished, professional, and unmistakably yours. With fast turnaround times, competitive pricing, and a true commitment to craftsmanship, Custom Genie is the partner you can trust to bring your brand to life — one custom product at a time.
Contact info
United States
- customgenie.com
3.7
Average
82 reviews
Replied to 73% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 1 month
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Very Disappointing
I placed an order through ASI- but not even the Customer Service rep knew...your website no longer converts an ASI order into a Custom Genie order.
When I finally received the sample order I paid for; it was GOLD instead of the SILVER I ordered. I lost Weeks of time to get the order placed properly, only to receive something I couldn't even send to my client.
6 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Thank you for your feedback. I’m sorry for the frustration you experienced with your order. The confusion around the ASI integration and receiving the incorrect color is not the experience we want for our customers.
I’m glad our team was able to connect with you, resolve the issue, and provide a credit toward your future order. We also took your feedback seriously and are reviewing both our ordering process and internal communication to prevent this from happening again.
We appreciate the opportunity to make this right and hope to deliver a much smoother experience on your next order. If there is anything else you need, feel free to reach out directly.
I wanted in a different color but they…
I wanted in a different color but they would not comply
2 March 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hi Emanu, we truly apologize for not accommodating your color request and for not responding to your concerns. We're going to make this right for you.
We're checking on this immediately. Our team will contact you directly to get this sorted and get you what you need.
We appreciate you sharing this with us.
sticker
i asked for gold metallic, got black in the mail. and the sticker is supposed to be placed on one by one. not all at once. more difficult and a waste of my money.
3 March 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hey Brandon, we truly apologize for sending black instead of gold metallic and for not fulfilling your order correctly. We're going to make this right for you.
We're investigating this right away. Our team will reach out to you directly to resolve this and understand exactly what you need.
We appreciate you sharing your feedback with us.
The name tags we ordered arrived and…
The name tags we ordered arrived and look great!
20 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Rick, thank you for your feedback—we’re glad everything arrived as expected,
I do like the new layout.
2 March 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Felix, thank you for your feedback—we truly appreciate it. Comments like yours help us continue improving and delivering a better experience for our customers.
Looks good
Product looks good but took a very long time to ship compared to when it was Stickers International.
26 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Eric, thank you for your feedback. We are pleased to hear that you are satisfied with the product. We appreciate your comments regarding the shipping time, and we remain committed to enhancing our turnaround times.
Pens came out great
28 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Danny, we are very pleased to hear that you’re happy with your order—thank you for your feedback.
Fast and not expensive
21 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Jean, thank you for your feedback. We sincerely appreciate your business and look forward to serving you again in the future.
Just what I ordered and quick and easy
Ordering was quick and easy, the package arrived quickly and I love my new pens.
Also, I love that I did not have to buy a huge quantity. On a lot of sites you have to buy a minimum of 100. I needed less than 20.
27 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Hilary, thank you for your kind feedback. We’re pleased to hear that the ordering process was smooth and that the flexibility in quantities met your needs.
We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again.
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Alfredo, Thank you for your continued trust in us. We’re pleased to hear you’re satisfied with the quality of your orders.
Reply from Customgenie
Shannon, thank you for your feedback. We’re pleased to know your experience with our platform and product met your expectations. Thank you for your business.
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Bill, thank you for your feedback. We truly appreciate your business and look forward to working with you again soon
I still haven't received my product and…
I still haven't received my product and it was a time sensitive order. I also never received an actual proof or a reply about a proof. Assuming this group has purchased Name Badges International, but all of our company history is gone and we have no way of ensuring the products match what we've had in the past - very disappointing
23 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hi Janel, we sincerely apologize for the inconvenience caused. We understand how important your timeline, proofs, and company history are to you. We're committed to resolving this and understanding your concerns in detail.
We're investigating this. Our team will reach out to you directly to get this sorted and make things right for you.
We appreciate you sharing your feedback with us.
Great custom pens
Pens work well! The custom logo looks exactly as it did when I designed it on the site. I was a bit worried at first because they don't give an estimate arrival for shipping. But it arrived very timely.
20 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Mario, Thank you for your feedback. We’re pleased to hear that your order met your expectations.
We also appreciate your comments and will continue working to enhance the overall response.
Quality control is non existent.
I made sure all my decals are perfectly aligned. They all came misaligned. I put in a remake request, they came back on the wrong stock and they were misaligned yet again. I ordered multiple sheets of the same decal, they are aligned differently on each sheet. Some of them float on the same sheet. This has been an ongoing issue. Extremely frustrated, and done ordering from these guys.
*Update*
I was contacted in reference to my review. Jessica from Custom Genie asked if I would like a refund or decals. She assured me they would be looked over to ensure they are centered as I laid them out. Once again they came misaligned. Decals on the same sheet were misaligned differently too. The decals in the vertical center of the sheet were perfectly centered, the ones on the right float to the left and the ones on the left float to the right. I ordered two sheet of ybis particular design. On the second sheet none were centered and they all floated down. Definitely a them problem and they can't fix it. Stickers International was an infinitely better company. I would give 0 stars if I could.
29 January 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hi Robert, we sincerely apologize for the alignment issues with your decals. We understand your frustration after multiple remake requests and inconsistent quality across your order.
We're investigating this immediately. Our team will reach out to you directly to resolve this and ensure we get this right for you this time.
We appreciate you sharing your feedback with us.
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Andrew, thank you for your kind feedback. We’re glad to hear you enjoyed your order.
Reply from Customgenie
Hello Bryan, thank you for your feedback. We truly appreciate your business and look forward to working with you again soon
Transition from NBI to Customgenie not smooth!
I'm not particularly happy with the transfer of process from Name Badges International to Customgenie. We had dozens of templates that we ordered from and they were all lost. Also there was no clear crosswalk betwen the NBI offerings and the Customgenie offerings. I think this could have been done a lot better. I know it should have been done a lot better.
18 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hi Maude, we sincerely apologize for the inconvenience with the transition from NBI to Custom Genie and the loss of your templates. We understand this has been frustrating. We're committed to making your experience better.
We're looking into this. Our team will reach out to you directly to understand your needs and find solutions.
We appreciate you sharing your feedback with us.
Poor Print Quality
Print quality came out very poor for the domed stickers despite my high-resolution art file.
17 February 2026
Reply from Customgenie
Hi, we sincerely apologize for the poor print quality on your domed stickers. We're committed to making your experience better.
We're looking into this immediately. Our team will reach out to you directly to resolve this.
We appreciate you sharing your feedback with us.
Stay Away
Issues uploading art online. Phone calls w/ their reps would give us conflicting information that no one could back up in an email as we tried to place orders online & email artwork. After reading reviews, I think we avoided a HUGE MESS!
2 March 2026
Unprompted review
Reply from Customgenie
Hi Kimberly, we sincerely apologize for the issues with the upload process and the conflicting information from our team. We understand your concerns.
We're looking into this to improve our process and communication. We hope you'll give us another chance to show you our standards are much higher than what you experienced. We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Labeled Verified, they’re about genuine experiences.
Learn more about other kinds of reviews.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.