So Just a One Star Then.....
So Just a One Star Then.....
I attempted to buy a 'natural minor' Lee Oscar harmonica from this company (via a listing platform). They list under 'Troubadour Music' because they published 'The Troubadour' in the 1900s. If you stumble on here because you are misdirected - their VAT number is GB234991441.
On their listing I was offered a reduced price 'open package' deal that the platform often offers purchasers - and 'Troubadour Music' listed one with a few quid discount.
On arrival the harmonica had arrived with the top and bottom plates covered (astonishingly liberally) in a sticky 'treacle-type' substance that was obviously some sticky confection deposited by someone who had tried it with a mouthful of confection. A vector for some possible nasty pathogen no doubt (so minus two stars).
This is apparently a long established possibly, well respected company. But not with me they aren't.
I can't believe they didn't know of its condition - as I don't think it was fit for purpose in this condition. I believe they cynically sent it out hoping not to see it again (so minus another star).
In consulting the instructions of another Lee Oscar I possessed (they sent it out without any of the usual gumf - minus one more star) I carefully cleaned it up with tepid running warm water - further proof that it was water based - consistent with a child's confection, and carefully extracted all the H²O, then left it in a warm space to dry naturally (because luckily ' Lee Oscars' are made of brass reeds and plastic.)
I then began the process of sending it back.
Why?
I have deliberately written this review in the wrong order.
Why?
Because I ordered a 'Natural Minor' harmonica and it wasn't a 'Natural Minor' harmonica (minus 4 stars).
The 'natural minor' Lee Oscar has a written green label with 'Natural Minor - labelled in the 2nd position key' on it. Furthermore the order number on the reverse is '1910N'
This was clearly notated on the order documents on the listing platform.
I was sent a 'sticky' yellow labelled 'Harmonic Minor' - without the usual descriptive documents (Ref 1910) - without the all important 'N' - and with a yellow label.
So I started the return process. I have no doubt that having cleaned it up; and such is my regard of their sales ethics, I wouldn't be surprised if they now relist at full price including the usual bumf!
So why the TrustPilot Review? Well the listing platform rejected my review - (minus another two stars).
To be able to get free postage on the platform I had to make up the order with some unnecessary purchases (I'm allergic to postal charges). So I only got back the 'reduced' sales price.
It's not possible to leave a review anywhere with a minus ten-star review. So just a minimum singleton star then.
Barnes & Mullins have replied in another place:
"Hi Charlie. I'm sorry you had a bad experience with the listing platform. We do not supply any open packet, special deal products to the platform. These 'deals' are returned products to them by customers, checked by the platform and resold by them without anyone else being involved. I
accept that the open packed deal should not have been in that condition, but i can assure you that no-one here would have had any opportunity to see that.. as if we had, it would not have been made available. However, that's not how the listing platform works sadly. They made a very bad judgement.
I can also see that you have been refunded, and rightly so.
So the Lee Oskar harmonicas you needed are available as brand new products from the listing platform, plus from lots of great music stores around the UK. All of these brand new products would have come via us at Barnes & Mullins and none of them would have ever have been played by anyone before.
My best to you
Alex"
This is me, Charlie: Hats off to Barnes & Mullins for their astonishingly fast, honest customer service to clear this up. They are a brilliant heritage company. The platform's warehouse ethics, however, get a big minus 10 stars."








