While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more

To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more

2.8

Average

TrustScore 3 out of 5

7 reviews

5-star
4-star
3-star
2-star
1-star

No history of asking for reviews

This company hasn't invited their customers, so reviews may not be representative

How this company uses Trustpilot

See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.

2.8

All reviews

(7)

4 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review

We perform checks on reviews

Companies on Trustpilot aren't allowed to offer incentives or pay to hide reviews. Reviews are the opinions of individual users and not of Trustpilot. Read more

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Disappointing Customer Service and…

UPDATE: Steelmade's owner personally stepped in and made things right.

After my initial disappointing experience, Mike Sisk, the owner of Steelmade, personally contacted me to acknowledge that my concerns about the company's advertised universal oven compatibility were valid.

Not only did he arrange to send me the correctly sized Pizza Steel at no additional charge and provide a fully prepaid return label for the original, but he also took the additional step of correcting the misleading language on Steelmade's website, clarifying its Fitment Guarantee, and improving its product-selection guidance to help prevent other customers from experiencing the same issue.

This is exactly how a company should respond when a legitimate customer concern exposes a problem.

While the initial customer service experience was frustrating, I have to give Steelmade considerable credit for taking responsibility and making meaningful changes rather than simply offering a one-time exception.

I'm updating my review to reflect that resolution. This experience ultimately demonstrated that the owner takes customer feedback seriously and is willing to act on it.

Disappointing Customer Service and Misleading Compatibility Claims

I purchased Steelmade's XL Pizza Steel for $73.02, partly because their website explicitly advertises it as "universally compatible with ovens" and prominently displays a "Fitment Guarantee."

Unfortunately, the 21-inch-wide steel does not fit my standard Frigidaire Gallery 27-inch wall oven, which has an interior width of 20½ inches.

I contacted Steelmade hoping to exchange the unused XL for their smaller model. Instead, I was told I'd have to pay $18.24 in return shipping, approximately 25% of my original purchase price. Although they eventually agreed to waive the 10% restocking fee, the exchange would still leave me paying approximately $81 overall for a smaller, less expensive product.

After several polite exchanges, Steelmade refused to cover the return shipping or provide a credit toward the smaller model. Despite my repeated questions, they never adequately explained how their advertised Fitment Guarantee applies when their product physically cannot fit inside a customer's oven.

I acknowledge that the product dimensions were listed, but if a company advertises universal compatibility and a Fitment Guarantee, customers should reasonably expect those claims to mean something.

What makes this particularly disappointing is that I had planned to purchase their flat-top cooking surface for my ceramic electric range, along with potentially other products. Those purchases will now go elsewhere.

All of this over an $18.24 return shipping charge. Steelmade had an opportunity to turn a minor compatibility issue into a positive customer experience and earn repeat business. Instead, they've lost a customer.

My advice: Measure your oven carefully and don't assume their advertised Fitment Guarantee means they'll cover return shipping if their product doesn't fit.

7 November 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Disappointing experience after one use

Disappointing experience after one use
I purchased the No Pre-season Flat Top and seasoned it before using it. After my first use, the surface developed significant rust.
Steelmade told me to scrub the rust off, re-season the surface, and continue using it. They refused my request for a return because it had already been cooked on.
I also filed a BBB complaint, but Steelmade maintained its position and refused a refund.
I understand that bare steel requires maintenance, but this was not the experience I expected from a new product after its first use. Very disappointing.

28 August 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 1 out of 5 stars

DO NOT buy Steelmade griddles

DO NOT buy Steelmade griddles! I purchased a griddle for my outdoor kitchen. Upon first use, and all subsequent uses, the griddle warps badly at low temperatures (350-375). I contacted Steelmade several times and they will not rectify the issue. In addition, Steelmade removes negative reviews from their website and only shows the positive reviews, and if you address concerns on Facebook they will block you!

16 June 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Their official company name is Bad Idea LLC. Yes it was...

BE AWARE BEFORE YOU BUY THAT THEY DO NOT DO EXCHANGES EVER IF YOU WANT TO EXCHANGE FOR A SET AT TWICE THE PRICE!! Oh and there's a 10% restocking fee and you pay return freight. Poor customer service policies, poor selection of products, poor management.
I'd so somewhere else if I were you.
I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS COMPANY!

22 June 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 3 out of 5 stars

Shipping & Ordering is Not Good!!!

Product seems decent, the ordering process and shipping process is horrendous. They hide bad reviews and there is no way to sort reviews on their website, so they are all good. Placed an order never heard anything about shipping, reached out said in was being made, then all of a sudden it ships. They shipped a 70 lb. griddle in a flimsy box packed with packaging peanuts, no support, no instructions, no receipt, no nothing!! Damaged box, falling apart, seriously????

11 September 2025
Unprompted review
Rated 2 out of 5 stars

Customer Service and Product usability lacking

I was very excited to receive and use my cooktop; however, I am disappointed.

The grill is not easy to use, as it is heavy, bulky, and needs to be removed in order to heat/cook pots and pans. The steel risers and grease catchers require placement each time the griddle is used. Additionally, when using as griddle the burners “burn” the griddle even at a low temperature.

I emailed the above to the company when they requested feedback - this was their last response: “ Thank you for your feedback. We appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts with us.
Best regards,
Annie
Customer Experience Team

No resolution to my issues.

22 July 2025
Unprompted review
Rated 2 out of 5 stars

This Company Refused My Business

This company refused to sell me the size flat top for a stove I wanted. Previously they had been a decent company to deal with. Can't imagine refusing to take someone's money but they did. Actually very glad they did. Found a seller on Etsy that will make the flat top to whatever size you want. It was thicker, better constructed and way cheaper. So if you are in the market for a flat top for your stove or BBQ I highly recommend heading over to Etsy. Save time, money and frustration.

19 July 2023
Unprompted review

Is this your company?

Claim your profile to access Trustpilot’s free business tools and connect with customers.

Get free account

The Trustpilot Experience

Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.

We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.

Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.

Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.

Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.

Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.

Take a closer look