Oak & Stars - NEVER AGAIN
Our stay at this property was deeply disappointing, and unfortunately did not reflect the standards advertised on Booking.com.
The directions provided were misleading and inaccurate. All mapping services place the property on Magdale, yet access is actually via Sandbeds. After a five‑hour journey, we spent twenty minutes circling the area trying to find the entrance — an avoidable frustration that could be solved with clear instructions.
The outdoor areas were poorly maintained: uncut and patchy grass, weeds throughout, a tired barked area, and even the only pot of flowers was half dead. This immediately gave the impression of neglect.
Several amenities were left unclean. The hot tub burner, barbecue, and indoor wood burner were all full of old ash and partially burned wood, with no attempt to prepare them for new guests. The hut exterior also needs attention, and the access steps had loose treads, which is a genuine safety concern. The seating shown in the listing did not match reality — we found only plastic chairs with no cushions.
On arrival, the hut was cold. Despite the unseasonably cold weather no heating had been switched on, not even in the bathroom. After a long journey, this made for an unwelcoming start.
Inside, the oven was in an unacceptable condition, clearly not cleaned for some time. Storage lockers contained untidy, crushed blankets, and the kettle was half full of stale water and had to be boiled twice before we could use it. Basic kitchen provisions were lacking — there was only one bowl, and the fridge’s ice box was unusable due to ice build‑up.
The welcome information consisted largely of rules and outdated guidance, including incorrect local details. Directions to the village were poor, and the walk itself is through an unlit wooded area and narrow alleys lined with nettles — something guests should be warned about, especially if returning after dark.
Overall, the property felt neglected and unprepared. My wife was very distressed by the condition of the accommodation, and although we were forced to stay for one night due to the late hour and distance from home, we left early and did not stay for the second night. The price paid does not reflect the standard delivered.
This review is intended as constructive feedback. The issues raised are not minor; they are fundamental aspects of guest comfort, safety, and hygiene that require urgent attention.
After complaining to owner (no success there) we complained to Booking.com we then received an aggressive 5 min rant on the phone from the owner who described us as a disgrace for suggesting her property was not up to scratch.
NEVER AGAIN!
21 May 2026
Unprompted review