I'll preface this review by saying: my wife is Jewish and I've had really good bagels - dense, chewy, and very flavorful. When you read the reviews here saying these New Yorker bagels are bready and h... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
I have been purchasing wholesale bagels from New Yorker Bagels for years. I had a few issues with delivery. They quickly took care of them. This last issue I had with delivery was a nightmare. I addre... See more
Believing we could find the ideal bagel with the 1st ingredient-Whole Wheat-we ordered a dozen (everything) at just under $40.00, shipping included special. They're much bigger than regular bagels. T... See more
We've ordered these bagels several times and love them. I cannot believe the negative reviews! People need to READ hearing instructions to bring our flavors! Two dozen bagels of choice for $44 which... See more
Company details
Information provided by various external sources
World's largest baker of hand-rolled New York City bagels, shipped fresh overnight. Kosher with Free Overnight Shipping.
Contact info
United States
- newyorkerbagels.com
2.5
Poor
28 reviews
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
Hasn’t replied to negative reviews
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
The are nothing but oversized Thomas'…
The are nothing but oversized Thomas' bagels. The consistency is HORRIBLE. I bought a pound of lox to serve with these bagels and after seeing the bagels, I put the lox back in the fridge. These bagels are not worthy of even a "shmear". Don't waste your money. Thankfully they have a "satisfaction guarantee". I'm requesting a refund and will dispute the charge if I don't get one....Yes, I am that disappointed.
8 January 2025
Unprompted review
Deliciousness!!
I have been ordering New Yorker Bagels for 7 months now. I have monthly shipment of 12 blueberry and 12 Cranberry Energy and I think they are amazing. I have also ordered pumpkin, plain, cinnamon raisin, French toast, onion, & pumpernickel. They are amazing. I heat according to their instructions by letting them thaw for 30 minutes and then into a 400 degree oven for 4 minutes. I was cutting in half and toasting but I think they are better done in the oven. My family is crazy over them too! Outside a bit crunchy and soft chewy inside, very good!
10 May 2024
Unprompted review
I would give 0 stars if i could
I would give 0 stars if i could. Always liked your bagels, favourite with sesame seeds. When i was buying from Tesco, Marks & Spencer, etc they were horrible! Not chewy, like sweet bead. But I enjoyed bagel from Newyork Bakery. But now British supermarkets started selling them with the sign NEW IMPROVED.
By my experience I know if it is "IMPROVED" it is always worse, company starts saving money and changing technologies. I notice the world "BOILED" disappeared!!! And the bagels became uneatable! Sweet bread!
I would not recommend people to buy them!!!
2 September 2024
Unprompted review
Definitely not the real thing
Definitely not the real thing.
Disappointed.
These are really fluffy bread doughnuts.
14 May 2024
Unprompted review
More “bread-like” than “bagel-like”
More “bread-like” than “bagel-like”. These are not at all like NY Bagels…
10 May 2024
Unprompted review
No Prize Winner
Believing we could find the ideal bagel with the 1st ingredient-Whole Wheat-we ordered a dozen (everything) at just under $40.00, shipping included special.
They're much bigger than regular bagels. This may suit those with mega appetites. However, we found-even after toasting-extremely soft to the bite. The lack of crunch, apparently lending to the ingredient mix is most unfortunate. The palpable taste of sodium @ 460mg is too much and steals the overall taste.
5 November 2023
Unprompted review
I ordered 6 Bialys and 6 Onion Bagels
I ordered 6 Bialys and 6 Onion Bagels, and Neither had a chew, Both were small. The bialys had no onions or poppy seeds. The taste left you wanting. It you would like to be disappointed by all means order some. Ill just wait until next time I am in NY to get some I suppose. For what these people charge they could do it right. Sad
24 February 2023
Unprompted review
Best bagel ever!
6 May 2022
Unprompted review
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.