mtgcardsmith.com Reviews 49

Amazing print quality and the website is incredibly easy to use for designing your own proxies. It can take mere minutes to setup each card thanks to the presets available.

Pretty great! there's loads of customization, even down to set logos and such. i've made a few home-brew joke cards and it's been pretty easy getting the cards together.

Quality is pretty great and foiling looks pretty good.

Site can get a little testy at times, but worth the trial and error.

Great customer service, fast shipping, and great quality cards.

I loved the ease of use of their site. The proxies are reasonably priced. I got the order in a few days, not weeks like other sites. The quality of the print is perfect. The weight of the card is the same as other MTG cards. I was so pleased with my first order, I promptly created another order before Christmas arrived. I highly recommend them.

I have received several orders from them, if it's just a card I want better art for, or a full custom card for fun they always come out great and they ship fairly quickly considering they are print to order. Highly recommend.

This is my second pick up. I made some previously for a family gift and they were universally well received. The card making interface has a few kinks to work out but overall the experience was great. Delivery was fast. I think from payment to the cards in my hand was 11 days. I'll be using the service again.

These cards are high quality!! Easy to create and they make games more fun to play!

It's a pretty easy to use site, I decided to make a few proxies of cards for Christmas, and it was quick and easy! I was able to upload the pictures I wanted and make them look amazing, shipping was a $5 flat rate and I'm now just hoping i wasn't too late for them to be here on Christmas!

They are so fast!!! Everything I ordered has looked beautiful, on great cardstock, and looks just like real mtg prints. The pricing is reasonable and everything has been delightful. My cards even got to me two days early!

I was glad to find mtgcardsmith when I was looking to make and print a card for my friends birthday. Card creation was intuitive and seamless. You truly have unlimited options when working on a card. Cards arrived quickly and looked stunning! I have seen genuine cards of lesser quality.
My only issue would be the foils that don't look as good but I was still happy. Also - they don't curl!
Overall very happy and will be using their services more I'm the future.

Proxy cards are of good quality and arrived quickly. Definitely a good source for proxies of cards outside your price range.

Print quality is decent and easy enough to use the interface - would recommend

Fast shipping, solid product. These cards would not pass for the real thing, but they are close enough (which is fine, because it prevents people from trying to pass them off as real.) Some colors (reds and blacks) come out a bit darker than expected, but now I know to adjust for that before submitting images. I will order more soon!

Ordered from them twice and was never disappointed! Card's have great quality and easy to read with the way they print them. Will definitely be ordering more in the future. They have a very quick turn around time as well. Took them about a week to print and send out the cards to me.

I'd been using this site on and off for a literal decade, and watched the site grow and blossom. However, the site changed ownership to someone who's all in it for the money, and as a result they implemented AI (a feature nobody asked for). Despite several pieces of constructive criticism from old and new site members alike regarding the implementation, as well as several significant community members speaking up against it, the new owner doubled down on the plan. They released the AI features within 24 hours of protests, banned several members from the Discord (some of which merely suggested to at least take time to consider the implications), and went on a tirade, openly admitting that they knew what they were doing violated Wizards Fan Content Policy and expressing a devil-may-care attitude towards the illegal scraping of artwork. He even went as far as to suppress information on-site to cover his tracks.

The website is pretty easy to navigate and use. Had no issues making personal cards and tokens. I have ordered multiple times and I have gotten my custom cards within a week and some change. Overall the cards turned out great, but personally not a fan of the foil.
Only criticism I really have is the lack of diversity in the token colors. As of right now you can only make mono colored tokens, i hope we can get multicolored in the future.

This was originally a 5 star review, but after customer service waited until AFTER printing my cards to respond (conveniently when you no longer qualify to cancel), I think it needed to change. I reached out immediately after my order to the email on their site they say to contact them through. I was turned around via a canned email a day later, that directed me to a contact form that didn’t exist. All around, I’m ending up with cards I don’t want and a service I won’t use going forward. Very unfortunate, I was really excited about this :/

The website is good and very simple to use, the proxies was great and came packaged very nicely. I was very satisfied with my cards that I got I will definitely keep ordering from here. The price is also reasonable and don't cost an arm and a leg.

The shipping was incredibly fast and right on time! The quality is indistinguishable from authentic Magic cards. I ordered from Germany, and the cards arrived in just 8 days—amazing!