Stay away from Houston Methodist
For about three weeks from late December to mid-January of this year, I experienced the worst imaginable service, compassion, and competence from a variety of people on the Houston Methodist(HM) staff. The experience was disastrous. I have had a prostatectomy at Cleveland Clinic and various procedures at Mayo and these institutions are light-years ahead of HM in terms of customer service, empathy, and general competence. The staff is woefully under-trained. As a group, they are lacking in basic patient relationship skills. Their interface with the public through telephone services and messaging is prehistoric and very user-unfriendly.
During that period I tried diligently to make an appointment to repair two hernias, including pre and post-op consultations and attendant labs and other tests, as well as a PSMA PET CT scan. A PSMA PET scan is an imaging test that detects prostate cancer metastasis anywhere in the body. Despite carefully and repeatedly explaining my situation to anyone who would listen (and there were few of these), both appointments were impossible to arrange.
Regarding the hernias, I was finally able to arrange a consultation with Dr. Patrick Reardon for January 27, 2026. During this conversation, we also discussed having the hernia repair within a few days of this because I was traveling from Mexico. Although I emphasized my current location out of the country and my short time window in Houston, no mention was made of Dr. Reardon't inflexible rule that he would need to see me in person two weeks after the repair. Nor was any mention made of any other pre or post op requirements. But the most troubling incident was when a receptionist happened to mention in passing that Dr. Reardon would be away for two weeks, including on January 27, the day of our consultation. I have never received any notice from anybody on Dr. Reardon's staff that he could not make our appointment.
I then tried numerous times, every day, to contact his office, by email and phone, to reschedule. I could never speak to a human being. I got the same message repeatedly: the person you are trying to reach is helping someone else, please leave a message and they will get back to you soon. I left numerous messages and NEVER received a reply, by text, email or phone. I tried many numbers associated with this department and got busy signals for hours and hours. It was obvious phones were left off the hook to give the impression the line was occupied.
I was able to establish a MyChart account. They could have sent me a message that way, but they never did. This scenario was not limited to Dr. Reardon's staff. After I learned he would not be there for my consultation, I tried to set up an appointment with other doctors, but the result was always the same. Nobody answers the phone, nobody returns calls, nobody sends texts or emails. It's a disgrace.
Trying to set up my PSMA PET scan was no different. Half of the employees I spoke with never heard of the test and some even told me that HM did not offer it (they do). Others directed me to other departments and phone numbers, all of which turned out to be incorrect. I finally spoke with someone who directed me to Nuclear Medicine, the right place. I then sent my Doctor's order for this test, through MyChart. The order was rejected, even though my doctor is a well-recognized expert in the field of prostate cancer and is also a professor, author, and lecturer on the subject. It was rejected because they only accept orders from Texas doctors.
Putting aside the legitimacy of this policy, I have since learned that HM had several options to honor its policy while also helping me. For example, they could have scheduled me for a brief consultation with one of their urologists. But they saw a non-Texas doctor on an order and simply hit "Reject." Employees don't have the training to suggest a workaround. They don't try to be helpful. Another excellent Houston clinic was able to provide this scan using the exact same order that HM claimed was "illegal" or "impossible" to accept. By refusing to help me with this order, HM chose administrative convenience over patient care.
I eventually found other places in Houston that helped me without a lot of red-tape and where I could speak to real people. Doctors actually returned my calls. Wonderful, compassionate technicians and other staff listened to me patiently and tried hard to be helpful.
I strongly recommend you stay away from HM. You can find much better options in the Houston area.
27 January 2026
Unprompted review