No returns, so my experience was 100% awesome
I bought 2 pairs of shoes from them within the European Union... so I felt safe in that the shipping would not be expensive. I was also able to return easily but as I did not test the return process, I likely did not run into the issues other people did.
I bought it with the intention of buying it and NOT returning it, although I would have, to recuperate even only half of my money, if it was really bad.
I bought 2 pairs to get free shipping, and I followed their directions VERY carefully. I am a US size 7 and I typically take a EU 37 in shoes (or so I thought), but when I checked the chart, it is EU 37.5, and the site said to round up 0.5 so I took a EU 38 and the sizing was perfection.
I am EXTREMELY happy with the shoes. Say what you want about their crappy return process, but their shoes were perfectly made, leather was very high quality, it was packaged so perfectly with even the detail of a plastic sticker on the bottom of the sole so that you don't ruin it when you wear it around the house on flat ground or carpet to try it out before keeping it.
I took their Ana Mink Canada shoes, these square toed ballet flat things, which will be perfect for autumn, and their sold-out-before-any-sale Vega Vidre Fuchsia sequin shoes which are the most beautiful shoes I have ever worn to date. (Difficult to keep clean though (the sequins are wild), so keep that in mind.)
The leather as I said, is very well made, sturdy and soft but not too soft, and the sizing was spot on.
I will 100% order again from them but have not found any other styles I like. I will just keep an eye on them as they add new things.