A Disappointing and Harmful Experience for a Returning Airbnb Guest
I booked a property in Oaxaca managed by AALOJAT, expecting a calm and comfortable stay. Instead, I left the experience feeling disrespected, misrepresented, and deeply disappointed.
There were two Black women staying in the home. The host, Olivia, never met either of us during the reservation. Despite this, I was publicly blamed in a review for “inspecting the housekeeper’s bag” and labeled as “demanding” and “distrustful.” These claims were based entirely on secondhand impressions, not direct interaction, and were assigned to me without any verification or evidence.
What made this particularly difficult is that I’ve stayed in many Airbnb properties across different countries and have consistently received positive reviews for being respectful, communicative, and professional. This experience stood out—not because of anything I did differently, but because assumptions were made about me that had no basis in fact.
When I raised this issue, the company responded defensively rather than reflectively. I was hoping for accountability or even just curiosity about how such a serious accusation could be directed at a guest they never met. Instead, the issue was minimized and eventually dismissed.
I do not take the act of writing public reviews lightly, but I feel a responsibility to inform other travelers—especially those from underrepresented backgrounds—that your experience may be filtered through assumptions that have little to do with who you are and more to do with who people assume you are.
I hope AALOJAT and its staff take this feedback seriously and invest in training or reflection that helps prevent similar incidents in the future.





